Judith Thurman's Amelia Earhart piece in this week's New Yorker is fascinating, as most of her work is (I loved her recent Laura Ingalls Wilder/Rose Wilder Lane piece), but I'm noticing a degree of absurdity creeping in to her deliciously catty, un-official "Takedowns Of Famous Heroines" series. In the Earhart piece, tied to the upcoming movie about her starring Hilary Swank, Thurman turns what seems to me to be an overly judgmental eye on the famously famous pilot. Here are a few of Earhart's "sins" in the article:
Thinking she had something to say even though she didn't even finish college:
"Read closely, however, Earhart’s life is, in part, the story of a
charismatic dilettante who lectured college girls about ambition yet
never bothered to earn a degree."
Doing whatever it is she supposedly did in this sentence about a '90s Apple ad (with the official Apple slogan, I might add.):
"The slogan that appeared with a
gauzy, doe-eyed photograph of Earhart in a white helmet was “Think
Different.” (She thought of herself not only as different but as a
special case to whom most ground rules didn’t apply.)"
(Who does that remind me of? Oh, ANY MAN WHO EVER DID ANYTHING.)
Being as un-shy as a particular famous man who is regarded around the world as a beloved, brave, and original hero:
"She quotes the great aviator Elinor Smith, who was still
flying in 2001, at eighty-nine: “Amelia was about as shy as Muhammad
Ali.”
Recent Comments